By North Atlanta Star Staff
North Atlanta’s pizza scene is as diverse as its neighborhoods, ranging from classic New York–style slices to Neapolitan pies with charred, blistered crusts. Whether you’re in Cumming, Johns Creek, Duluth, Suwanee, Roswell, or Alpharetta, there’s no shortage of places turning out pizzas worth writing home about.
In Cumming, Giovanni’s has built a loyal following with its foldable New York–style slices, tangy sauce, and generous toppings. The place feels like a true neighborhood hangout — the kind where the staff knows your order and the garlic knots are just as famous as the pizza. Not far away, Mellow Mushroom delivers its signature stone-baked pies in a funky, family-friendly space, perfect for lingering over dinner.
Over in Johns Creek, Alessio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria blends New York tradition with a family-owned warmth. Their thin crust is crisp but still has that satisfying chew, and the toppings range from classics like pepperoni to more adventurous combos. Another local favorite is Roma’s Pizza, known for its hearty Sicilian pies and lunch specials that draw regulars from nearby offices.
Duluth adds a more artisanal edge with O4W Pizza, famous for its Grandma Pie — a rectangular, thin-crust pizza with a crisp bottom, sweet tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella. The vibe is casual, the flavors are bold, and the quality keeps people driving in from other towns.
In Suwanee, Johnny’s New York Style Pizza keeps it simple and satisfying, with large slices, a kid-friendly menu, and plenty of space for team celebrations after the big game. For those looking for something a little different, Pizzeria Lucca in nearby Roswell offers true Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a wood-fired oven imported from Italy, with a blistered crust that’s airy yet substantial.
Roswell itself is a pizza lover’s paradise. Antico Pizza Napoletana has a location here, serving Naples-style pies with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil — all cooked in less than 90 seconds in 900-degree ovens. Fellini’s Pizza is another mainstay, loved for its relaxed vibe and classic slices that taste just as good at midnight as they do at lunch.
In Alpharetta, the options only get more impressive. Crust Pasta & Pizzeria offers both traditional and creative specialty pies alongside homemade pasta dishes, making it a great all-rounder. Campania is a must for purists, with VPN-certified Neapolitan pizza that rivals what you’d find in Italy. From their dough fermentation to their choice of toppings, every detail is dialed in.
What makes the North Atlanta pizza scene so special is its balance of comfort and craft. You can grab a quick slice on your lunch break, enjoy a wood-fired pie with a glass of wine on date night, or order a giant, topping-loaded pizza for a family gathering — all without leaving your own community.
The next time the craving hits, skip the delivery chains and try one of these local gems. You’ll not only get a better slice — you’ll be supporting the restaurants that make North Atlanta’s dining scene so vibrant.
Pizzeria Links & Info
- Giovanni’s (Cumming) – giovannisnypizza.com
- Mellow Mushroom (Cumming) – mellowmushroom.com
- Alessio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria (Johns Creek) – alessiosrestaurant.com
- Roma’s Pizza (Johns Creek) – romaspizzajohnscreek.com
- O4W Pizza (Duluth) – o4wpizza.com
- Johnny’s New York Style Pizza (Suwanee) – johnnyspizza.com
- Pizzeria Lucca (Roswell) – pizzerialucca.com
- Antico Pizza Napoletana (Roswell) – anticoatl.com
- Fellini’s Pizza (Roswell) – fellinisatlanta.com
- Crust Pasta & Pizzeria (Alpharetta) – crustpasta.com
- Campania (Alpharetta) – campaniaga.com
