North Atlanta, Then: Roswell’s Old Methodist Church as a Warehouse

A 1936 federal survey photograph preserves Roswell’s Old Methodist Church during its years as a feed and grocery warehouse.

By NAS Weekend Desk

In August 1936, Historic American Buildings Survey photographer L.D. Andrew recorded a plain brick building on Alpharetta Street in Roswell. Its church years were already behind it. Dunn Feed and Grocery Company then owned the former Old Methodist Church and used it as a warehouse.

The photograph catches that working chapter clearly: the old sanctuary has a warehouse sign across the front, with goods stacked near the entrance. Its heavy cornice and shallow gable still mark the building’s earlier life. The HABS history card dates the structure to 1858 and records damage by federal troops in 1864; later Roswell records date the former Methodist church to 1859.

The building became Roswell Masonic Hall in 1952. Its next use is still being shaped. The City Council voted in August 2024 to preserve it rather than remove it for the Green Street project. In October 2026, the council authorized the Roswell Development Authority to negotiate a reuse plan for a live-music and performing-arts venue.

The 1936 image preserves a moment when a pre-Civil War landmark was neither museum nor monument. It was part of the ordinary commercial life of Roswell.

The former Old Methodist Church in Roswell, photographed in August 1936 while it served as a feed and grocery warehouse. L.D. Andrew, Historic American Buildings Survey, Library of Congress, HABS GA,61-ROSW,2–1. Public domain.

Sources: Library of Congress photograph and HABS history card; City of Roswell meeting record; 2024 preservation decision; October 2026 reuse update.

Share a piece of your North Atlanta

Have a photograph from growing up here, perhaps a school day, family gathering, neighborhood shop, ball game or ordinary moment that means something to you? We’d love to see it. Photos from your parents’ or grandparents’ albums, and from more recent years, are welcome too. Send a digital copy to info@northatlantastar.com with “North Atlanta, Then” in the subject line. Tell us where and roughly when it was taken, who is pictured if you know, and the story behind it. Include your name, town and the photographer’s name if known. Please send only photographs you own or have permission to share for publication. Selected photographs and memories may appear in North Atlanta Star, with permission and credit.

Also in this week’s Sunday Edition: read Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “John Inglefield’s Thanksgiving” in The Sunday Page, and test local performance-space history in the Sunday Quiz.

Home of the Week

Two decks at Ward’s Crossing in Johns Creek

Johns Creek · $689,900 · Townhome

Tour the home
Keep it. Pass it on.